CAUTION: Spoiler Alert
I went to see Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix last week and it was great. I had purposefully kept my expectations low—since I had not been so happy with HP and the Goblet of Fire—but I didn't need to.
Number Twelve Grimmauld Place and the DA and Harry's detentions with Umbridge and the Hall of Prophecies were all like we had dropped into them out of the book. I especially liked the purring, meowing kitty plates mounted on the walls in Umbridge's office. The sound design made me want to look around the theater for all the kittens who had escaped from the pet store. (and to take one home, of course)
New additions Kreacher, the thestrals and Mrs. Figg were well done but the best has to be Luna Lovegood. I'm so glad she was given several scenes in the movie in which to shine. Lucius Malfoy was again a superb bad guy and this time he had sexy fighting robes and a new evil sidekick, Bellatrix Lestrange.
The only complaint I have is that I wished it could've been twice as long. So much that I loved in the book was sacrificed to tell the story within a reasonable time. Here are some of the things they had to omit:
- the screaming portrait of Sirius' mum
- the cleaning of Number Twelve, especially the Doxies
- Mrs. Weasley encountering the boggart
- Hermione and Ron as prefects
- S.P.E.W. and Hermione's knitting
- Quidditch in its entirety: Ron as Keeper, Harry's ban, "Weasley is Our King"
- Percy's letter to Ron vilifying Harry
- Lockhart and Neville's parents at St. Mungo's
- Harry's outlawed story in The Quibbler
- Firenze as Divination professor
- Hermione's jinx revealed on Marietta Edgecombe's face
- the staff of Hogwarts ignoring, yea, encouraging pranks after Dumbledore is removed as Headmaster (oh, the twins' swamp!)
- studying for and taking their OWLs
- Hagrid's firing, McGonagall taking four Stunners
- the rotating room, the brain room (Ron!), the time room in the Dept. of Mysteries
- Harry blowing up at Dumbledore and destroying the many whirring trinkets in his office
With that list you may wonder what
was in the movie. Well, you'll just have to go and see.